No Wonder Healthcare Is So Expensive!

I am thinking that we might really need to just burn the healthcare system to the ground and completely start over.

Although I am pretty experienced with healthcare, the financial piece is one that I haven’t really been as involved in since I am still on my parent’s insurance and they pay the bills. Knowing that I can’t do that forever, I have been starting to pay more attention. Last weekend, I was home in Tampa, and my mom was muttering something about our new insurance and the bill. So, I decided to take the opportunity to learn more. I don’t know if others know how this all works, but I didn’t, so I am going to explain what I learned. Brace yourselves. It’s ridiculous.

Due to my rare disease, I get two infusions in the hospital each month. I am admitted to the hospital for about 23 hours. It is the same treatment every single month. Exactly the same. Every once in a while I might need more meds for nausea or an extra lab test or something minor, but essentially it is always exactly the same.

Hospitals (and doctors in general) create this thing called a Chargemaster that has the rate for every procedure or group of procedures that they bill insurance companies and self-pay patients. Medicare has standard rates for all procedures, however those rates get increased in some areas because they are more expensive areas, such as New York or San Francisco. However, these rates are all based on a base payment and just adjusted for the city. But, the hospital knows that some insurance companies will pay more than others and they don’t want to limit their payment if someone will pay more, so they jack up the rate that they bill for everyone. So, let’s say Medicare will pay $100 for something like a Chest X-Ray. Well, Cigna might pay $150, Blue Cross might pay $135, Aetna might pay $200, and some insurance company that they don’t have a contract with might pay $300. So, the hospital makes the rate something like $700 to be absolutely sure that they charge more than the highest possible amount someone might pay. Then, they write off the $500 difference between the $700 and the $200 for Aetna, and the $400 for the insurance company that they don’t have a contract with. The self-pay patient has to negotiate with the hospital, and hopefully they get a rate at least 25 -50% of the $700. But there is no requirement for the hospital to have a self-pay rate that is any specific rate.

So, what freaked my mom and I out this weekend is the difference that my hospital was paid for the EXACT same medications, with the EXACT same doctor, at the EXACT same hospital with the EXACT same nurses. I have had three insurance companies in the last 12 months. The pictures and table below show what they have paid at the same hospital and treatment.

 

Insurance Company Rate Charged Amount Written Off Amount the Hospital Received
GEHA (Aetna Contract) $28,405.99 $7,669.62 $20,736.37*
Blue Cross Alabama $29,756.15 $25,930.71 $3,827.45
Cigna $28,755.17 $25,436.17 $3,319.00**

*$4,260.90 was what I (the patient) had to pay       ** $221.82 was what I had to pay

The difference in cost to the system is $202,907.04 a year just for me!

I understand the value of having negotiated rates, and I get that insurance companies can argue that they bring patients or offer some other competitive reason for the hospital to give them a discount. BCBS and Cigna were fairly close with about $500 difference or 13%. However, I cannot possibly imagine how one insurance company has to pay 5.41 times more for the exact same thing! Literally over $16,000 more!!

So after all this you might be wondering how why does this really matter to me if it only makes the insurance companies pay more in some cases? This is actually one of the biggest causes of heath care being so expensive because the insurance company paying more means that your family will need to pay more in premiums and in out of pocket expenses. NO WONDER HEALTH CARE IS SO EXPENSIVE.

But wait… there’s more.

So, I asked my mom to get me some more examples. My dad started searching through the millions of Explanation of Benefit or EOB files we have (by the way, why are these still sent by paper??). These EOB reports are what explain this whole system of what was billed, what is allowed by the insurance company contract, what the insurance company is paying, and how much the patient owes.

Over the years, I have had this exact same treatment now at three different hospitals and with multiple different insurance companies. I wanted to see how much these vary. These additional ones are shown in pictures and the table below.

 

Hospital Insurance Company Rate Charged Amount Written Off Amount the Hospital Received
EAMC GEHA (Aetna Contract) $28,405.99 $7,669.62 $20,736.37*
EAMC Blue Cross Alabama $29,756.15 $25,930.71 $3,827.45
EAMC Cigna $28,755.17 $25,436.17 $3,319.00**
FHWC Cigna $47,171.56 $29,435.05 $17,736.51
ACH Cigna $19,491 $9745.98 $9745.95
ACH Blue Cross North Carolina $18,279 $8,832.23 $9,447.79

I know it is a lot of numbers, and it has been mind-blowing to me. So, just to make sure we are all on the same page.

  • I had the exact same Cigna plan for three different hospitals. The charges for the same infusion at the three hospitals were $28,755, $47,171, and 19,491. I never knew that it was that different.
  • The reimbursement from the SAME insurance company for three different hospitals was $3,319, $17,736, and $9,745. I never knew that picking a different hospital could make THAT much of a difference. In fact, the cheapest one is where I have felt I have gotten the best care, had the best nurses, and had the least amount of complications.
  • The reimbursements overall ranged from $3,319 to $20,736. How is that possible? Why do we allow this?
  • Two different Blue Cross Plans paid drastically different amounts – $3,827 to $9,447. I would have thought they would be similar since they are both Blue Cross?

The thing that has me wondering the most is how can we help patients understand this? How can we choose hospitals that have the best rate AND the great quality? In my case, I think the lowest price is actually also the best quality, but it could have been that the lowest reimbursement was lower quality. How can we help people evaluate this? How can we get the difference in fees to be lower? Maybe everyone should post their bills? Can we require hospitals or insurance companies to publish their rates?

I have seen on twitter that hospitals had to post their prices. I went looking at these three hospitals but I couldn’t figure out the charges. Even if I had, I would have thought All Children’s (ACH) was the best deal because it had the lowest actual charge, but the reimbursement rates in their contracts were actually higher.

I am starting to understand the basics of why the financials of our healthcare system are such a mess. I have focused on improving the patient experience, keeping patients safe, and improving treatment options that are available. I guess now I need to learn more about the financial aspect of health care. And just from researching this in one day, I can already tell that it is just as messed up as the rest of the health care system.

I wish there was an easy to use app that would let me compare prices and quality so that I could easily make a decision on where to go. Instead, I have to attempt to decipher what the vague numbers on the hospitals website actually mean and try to guess which insurance company pays the best rate to the hospital. Surely we can do better. We must do better.

I am sure there is a lot I don’t know. Please share comments!

 

 

7 thoughts on “No Wonder Healthcare Is So Expensive!

  1. Wonderful! I think you could improve the second table by including the dates of service and also what the amount was your family was required to pay in the last column. Also, unless you have a reason not to list the hospital names, you should do that below the table as this may help someone evaluating getting some service at those hospitals.

    Like

  2. Blessings on Jeanne Pinder of ClearHealthCosts for tweeting about this!

    Morgan!! Superstar! Seriously, as you probably know, I’ve been blogging about this subject since 2012, and you NAILED it. Perfect angle, perfect line of thinking, and absolutely perfect outrage.

    There is more to it than just the stupid, inflated, and totally fictional insurance margins and bogus negotiated prices. If you want more background on all this just ask (more rat-holes to go down), but here are two starters from my blogging:
    _____

    First: American Healthcare: A Malignant Tumor That Can’t Stop Killing Its Host sums up the three cardinal observations that have never budged as long as I’ve been watching:

    1. The system wants to grow, and is good at it. <= like a malignancy

    2. It’s not necessarily getting the job done <= the study discussed here appalls me but is GOLDEN evidence that the system is oriented around other purposes, not "getting the job done."

    3. Bottom line, price and value are out of whack. Result: toxicity.
    ____

    The other is the classic 2006 health economics article "Chaos, behind a veil of secrecy," which I’ve blogged about many times.

    Finally: it took a long long time for it to sink in, but I eventually learned NOT to blame anyone I ran into in a hospital or elsewhere, unless they were at the sort of management level where it’s their job to DEFEND THEIR MARGINS over whether you’re getting what you need. Those people often don’t realize it but they ARE the agents of the madness that makes everything in that Malignant post happen.

    You’re spot on. Go for it. Follow your nose, because it’s smart.

    (And don’t tell him I said so, but when Matthew Holt takes a moment for words of encouragement, it means something. “Keep it up” indeed.)

    Like

  3. Wonderful job, Morgan. I recall the way your mom has spoken about doing her part with CareSync to help makes sense of a crazy system.

    Comparing prices AND quality — aye, there’s the rub. Relatively uncomplicated, perhaps (in the sense anything in health care can be uncomplicated) for a relatively standardized procedure. But what about for more complex care services? And what about finding out information on doctors?

    I just wrote about the need for that kind of information for the truly sick in a First Opinion piece for STAT News entitled, “Health care price tags won’t find you the best doctor.” Here:

    https://www.statnews.com/2019/03/07/health-care-price-tag-quality-care/
    Best of luck,
    Michael

    Like

  4. Well researched and well written. Another big cost impact, you may find interesting to delve into, is federal and state mandates on helathcare (hospitals, doctors and insurers). You might find yourself surprised by how much is regulated and the cost impact. Especially for states with heavily regulated healthcare (NM is one I am aware of).

    Like

Leave a Reply to epatientdave Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s